Aita for not giving my sister the wedding gift she wanted. My birthday/Christmas gifts were often makeup and dolls.

Help keep the sub engaging! Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ. I can't imagine in my wildest dreams asking her for more money than she gave us. My sister who we will call Katie had been planning her wedding for over a year. In 2021, the cancer came back in a different spot. If you wanted to gift her shit, it would be nice but she should have never presumed and OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole: i told my sister to not come to my wedding after she got upset because i said i would pay for her bridesmaids dress. ” AITA for not giving my sister my gift card? This is very dumb but I wanted a second opinion. You've agreed to get married; you've set a date, you're engaged. I have an identical twin sister, Lena. 5 hours long on this post. I’m refusing to give my best friend a wedding gift or go to his bachelor party Help keep the sub engaging! Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ. I’m not super close to her or her fiancé, but I love weddings so I said yeah I’ll go. My friend works the stressful job, my cousin does not work. She went onto explain that her sister asked their parents for financial help, but A few of our friends do have under 13 kids but I said if they wanted the kids could come, since I knew them, but they were all said they'd get a sitter so it was fine. We got engaged in June 23, and decided on the wedding date a year and half in advance for everyone’s convenience. I let her stay for free excluding expenses. She asked her cousins and found out all of them got the same gift. They're versatile for most weddings and it's a one-time investment. ”. It is part of my trauma; being around them for me comes with a sense of responsibility that reminds me of the neglect I suffered at the hands of my family. A few weeks ago the affair partner reached out to me. 3. AITA for not giving them 50% of our cash wedding gifts to my in-laws when we didn't agreed on that. Our wedding cost around 700k, paid by him and his parents. The bride and groom can dress up. It’s not just anxiety it’s a full-blown phobia. Get a gift card of $50 (or a little more) to go towards a concert, cruise or hot air balloon experience etc. My sister has her dream wedding planned, she has been dreaming of her wedding all her life and has everything down to the t. Not enough info. I went no contact with her 5 years ago. Reply. AITA for not letting my half sister wear anything of my mom's on her wedding day? Not the A-hole. I almost wonder if she thought thought she was going to be helping by giving you a new good memory for that day instead. They enjoyed the photos, paid my sister anyways, and still hire my sister as a priority, but still invite her to weddings as a friend, just listen to her advice on photographers. tahernator. (F30). And it's absolutely never appropriate to demand a new gift after re SIL and most of her family is upset with me because of a recent situation. ” The woman acknowledged that she “politely declined to lend [Amy] the purse,” due to how meaningful I told her that's not the same, she knows it, and the dress was never hers to do with what she wanted. I feel like it will be an easier boundary to say that I'm not giving her any of my own, actual money. May 24, 2024 · Getty. The Bride + Groom thought it was hilarious. Your sister doesn’t even have basic respect, let alone any joy for you and your partner. This, however, means that I won't be attending. invite your sister and don’t tell your parents until they see her the day of, everything will have already been paid for by then. 2) I am the only one in my family that can help her without growing in debt myself. I have an intense fear of flying. You are not invited to the wedding, so I think NTA, but since you know Casey and interact with her and she is nice to you with work related things, I suggest you give her a card that says Congratulations on Your Wedding. Edit 1: at the time I was in a relationship with someone and the guy and i been talking about how we wanted our wedding to be and he did have a say and we had agreed to put the Corpse Bride theme in play. Mano_Mama3510. Feb 13, 2024 · The baby of my sister is okay. anbaric26. AITA for not giving a wedding present I promised because I was uninvited? Not the A-hole. Once when we went to the mom's house to get the other sister, mom saw me and sneered, then asked my older sister in a nasty voice "Is that's Jim's daughter!?". Just bear with me for a moment. I (30f) have a half sister (23f) who'll be getting married sometime in 2025. OP has the chance to give her sister an amazing gift and is choosing not to because she wants to be first. My parents' money is theirs Typically in my family/friends we put money in a card for the bride and groom since there’s usually a bridal shower. AITA for not giving my sister my mom's wedding set after she said I could have it. That said she's already borrowed a lot from you, she's demanding money and she screamed at you. Then my sister stands and holds up an unopened gift for our mother. His parents, my brother and SIL show blatant favoritism towards him over his younger sister Lou (9f). She chose a place in Hawaii which meant. However, you're also the AH because regardless of her motives she paid for your college tuition. I’ve had panic attacks on planes before and even canceled trips last minute. Apparently your sister has her own, unique motives. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. AITA for refusing to go to my half sister’s wedding. OH HELL NO IT'S GOING TO BE A GIFT. First, I wasn’t added to the bridal party. My mother-in law (which I will be forever grateful) was in I am low contact with my parents and sister, but apparently she is engaged and wants me to be a part of the wedding party. , that would be a nice gesture as a new coworker. My mom was diagnosed with uterine cancer back in 2018. The actual photographer was crap, and my sister knew there work, so made sure to bring her camera and take some additional shots to give to the family for free. ertrinken. Please don't try to sell or fundraise through this community, and please don't be an Asconaut to other people. That would be something where you meet with them privately, discuss what you'd like to do, and find out what they actually want and need. But I hate attention on me so I never got to upset. Basically she can't be bothered and wants to know if not being bothered to support your sister at her wedding makes her an arsehole. My husband and I were paying for our own wedding. Edit 2: from a lot of comments I’m seeing about “owning the idea” I know I can AITA for not giving my sister the wedding gift she wanted because of how she treated my girlfriend? (r/AmITheAsshole)Source: Recent_Exit1536 on Reddit (link OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole: I didn’t give my wife the validating answer she wanted. Sister is one of the angriest people I've ever met. At the reception, my sister got mad that Connor was wearing a tie, but didn't say much after that. My baby shower she announced she eloped. She started crying, said that she was just extremely stressed, and that we shouldn’t have taken it to heart. I’ll also be distancing She said "fine" and that was it. Mom brushes it off because Sister's a tiny blonde who weighs 105 lbs soaking wet, but she has rages that can I do think you should give her some sort of gift for her wedding and it's not up to you how she spends her money. Probably not 600 dollars cool, but cool anyway. Maybe this will help her learn, but if not, at the very least you don’t have to worry about her shitty behaviour on your big day. Me sister was sad wanted DYSON AIR THING FOR HAIR so me am give her DYSON HAIR PRODUCT to her. Your friends were generous, especially given their status as students. Have the bridal party dress up. My little sister Emily's getting married in a few months. The 16th one was only right because grandpa forced his way into the kitchen to help that year. As a result, sadly Josh has grown a little entitled. 2) I might be the asshole for not validating her when that’s what she wanted. You’ll be an AH still but a morally right justified AH. My (28M) sister (24F) is getting married at the end of this month on the same day as my child's first birthday party. I changed the names of my sisters for privacy reasons. NTA, there is no conceivable universe where her walking down the aisle on your wedding day, at the location of your wedding, wearing a wedding dress will be "just between the two of you" and not detract from your day. We told her that it was our money, and after how she behaved, we did not want to give it to her. So she very much seems to be winning the asshole crown in this situation. He agreed, but said that he needed time and that he would need her opinion constantly. The sister has given her five months notice which is plenty of time to work out arrangements. However, in your situation, NTA. I give you The Final Win. That purse is extremely valuable to me, and the thought of something happening to it makes me anxious. It's rude of her to even ask. Literally EVERY wedding gift was a different toaster. I was a bit confused about what she wanted, so first I asked if she wanted me to just get her, her husband, and my fiancée's siblings more Most people in their late 20s, 30s and 40s have designated wedding clothes. She expected each guest to help pay for part of the wedding, which included travel expenses and an extravagant gift. Expecting guests to scavenge thrift stores bc the bride and groom think it would be fun is annoying. Some people asked for an update, and here you have it. I told Bertram that I really did not want a complete stranger in my wedding pictures, and certainly not someone my sister would only have been dating a few weeks, maybe a month. She wanted me to tell his family because she wants her child to have a relationship with his family and be connected to his culture. My little brother (10 years younger) was not my best man and he accepted that, because it was my choice and not his. Tell us about any non-violent conflict you have experienced; give us both sides of the story, and find out if you're right, or you're the asshole. My brother got married with SIL at a small church by our house. YWNBTA if you discuss your feelings with your brother though on all this, including his fiancé’s behavior towards you. Help keep the sub engaging! Your sister for making a demand to pay for half of her dress. (15F and 12F) Yesterday, my mom came in to ask me to ask if I could give her my ULTA to my 15 year old sister. I told her me and the boys are leaving and she told me "don't you dare cause a scene at MY WEDDING, Nia LifeguardOld4047. Well just this past week Bertram and I sent out our wedding invitations, and they read “We have reserved __ seat (s) in your name. I’m in America. My sister (33 F) is getting married October 1st. Most of the guests knew each other well already, and we all colluded to buy them toasters. I am not really sure but this was in September so she was less than 3 moths pregnant when that happened so barley showing if that gives you an estimate. She said she just wanted to let me know before she sent the official invite because of Mia. It was only worth around 250k at the time and was recently valued at 320k. That is much less than I would charge anyone else. Its rude AF to hand someone their gift back. Fighting won't find that solution though. People will forget your wedding 20 years from now but you and her won't forget who won that day. She wants me to give her the same experience I've given my friend. As you can imagine, it's hard to find a babysitter for them on a Not the A-hole. As for my mother she was officiating the wedding. I feel this way with my needier sister as the less needy sister. Additionally, 5k seems like a ridiculous amount for a wedding invite your sister and wait til you can pay for your own wedding so your parents don’t have any control over it. My reason for refusing to put a gift in for this wedding and puttting my name down on a Lubby Dubby card that my partner would write is because this feels fake and feels more than being civil . But after that, the pregnancy was all anyone talked about for the rest of the day, and the days after that. The time to fix your relationship with your half-sisters was before you were even born, and she didn't do it then. The other question I got is how far along my sister was when this happened. I said no, because I was going to use it to buy a gift for my friend. I (18F) recently decided I’m not attending my sisters (21F) wedding. I wanted to be real to myself and her. There's a better solution here. My future SIL said that me and my sister would be her Jan 29, 2024 · "AITA for telling my mom I am not comfortable with the speech she wants me to give at her wedding and I won't give it?" My mom is engaged to a guy called George and they want their wedding to symbolize the creating of a new family unit with me (15f) and mom and George and his three kids (ages 8, 6 and 5). •. MID reception have the dj announce "couples battle" and go full WHITE GIRLS on em. I'd pay the $5,000 and write on the check - reimbursement for college tuition. I said I wouldn't do this and simply passed along their contact information. My wife was devastated. None of my sister's other bridesmaids are stepping up either (they all have a reason for why they can't spend more time on my sis's wedding). My wedding day she was admitted to the hospital and not sure if she’d be able to come. AITA For Inviting my Twin Sister Wedding Dress Shopping And Not Her Mother? Not the A-hole. 2. Weddings are about celebrating the couple and their relationship. Also as an EMT: please for the love of whatever diety you belive in, stop driving all together. 4. One man explained to the internet that when his sister got engaged last year, she asked his 17-year-old son to make We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Subreddit Announcements Happy Anniversary, AITA! The Asshole Universe is Expanding, Again: Introducing Another New Sister Subreddit! Hi, it’s me again. If that was her intention, it backfired spectacularly. I am not rich. My birthday/Christmas gifts were often makeup and dolls. AITA for not attending my sisters wedding because of her dress code. TLDR: Best friend of 8 years got mad at me for refusing to help pay for her huge wedding without expecting to pay me back. And boy We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. We have been dating since 10 years and have been saving up for the wedding since K said that my mother and me did nothing for her the entire engagement and that I did not congratulate her at all. Part of it for me is that I am nervous about my sibling coming to me for financial help when my parents are no longer around to bail her out. So for example for my Fiancé’s family his reads, “We have reserved 4 seat (s) in your name. Explain to your sister that you have no way of getting to her wedding without risking to siriously harm yourself and others. Bride, 23, Slammed for Charging Guests $10 to Attend Utah Wedding and Posting Registry on Social Media. Then my sister continued with her tirade of “what have you done for me? I refuse to pay for my sister's dream wedding and only gave her 3k gift. "AITAH for Not Inviting My Sister to My Wedding After She Ruined My Proposal" During this dinner, my sister asked my son (17m) to make her wedding dress. Maybe it's finding another way to honor mom. Contest mode is 1. Everyone was on board, except my older sister, F. She called us furious for discriminating against her. Out of the blue, my older sister gave us a large, cash wedding gift bc she wanted to help us pay for the wedding and honeymoon. It was always something. ) For something like a house down payment or a car, that's not something to just give as an unsolicited gift. AITA for not postponing our wedding to accommodate my SIL? Not the A-hole. You don’t know this couple well, you’re not attending the event, and you sent a small, generic gift (which you didn’t have to do) simply to be kind. Award. So my (25f) sister and her (26m) fiancé are lower class (her 170k) (him 110k) student loan debt (interest made it grow crazy) and 18k medical debt and 35k credit Amy doesn't own any designer bags and really wanted one to complete her wedding look. I'm happy for her, but I'm not attending the wedding. I will be attending my older brother’s wedding soon and I really don’t want to give him money. Jun 13, 2024 · I said I could do it for about $1,000 for what she wanted. Emma kept asking to allow her kid but I told her multiple times, before the wedding, the rules changed. Jan 18, 2024 · NTA, your sister had the right right to pick any day she wanted for her wedding just as you had the right not to attend because she picked a day that is hard for you. It turns out Emily's way over budget, and the main culprit is the dress. . Throughout the whole lead up, my brother and his fiancé have been treating me like an inconvenience. she is getting the gift she wants… kinda. We've always been super close, so I'm thrilled for her, but honestly, the whole wedding planning thing has been a bit much. Maybe it's sharing the dress. And everyone was happy! Girllllllll you need to invite her to that wedding. (Well, not now, since the wedding is over, but you get the idea. I asked the seamstress for the rest of my wife's dress and had Olivia tell my wife in person what she had done. Feb 28, 2023 · And a recent post on the AITA subreddit just might take the dress drama cake. And I’ve got to say, the ones who gave me tips on how to be petty made me laugh, but after thinking about it I decided to simply not attend the wedding. I have since canceled the payments I made that day and told her I won't be paying another cent to her wedding. (Excuse me for any mistakes English is not my first language) some background information I (17m) and my brother (19m) are the children of a broken marriage my father (68m) was not a great father he neglected me and my brother our whole lives and was mentally abusive towards my mother (52f AITA for not giving my brother a wedding gift. My sister recently approached me to plan everything for her: bridal shower, bachelorette, and the actual wedding. I have never known so much peace. Ever. Jul 11, 2024 · The woman began her story by establishing that both her sister and her fiancé are in their early 40s. Shit hit the fan. "I just can't understand why my 7-month-pregnant sister doesn't want 60 people tromping through her beautiful new family home for a week during a worldwide pandemic!" Dec 20, 2023 · NTA, and congrats on getting the best Xmas gift of all: the gift of silence from entitled brothers and SILs! The tradition is simple: you give your mother and sister jewelry. Hire a choreography for you and your man. ADMIN. That’s really not the point of the post though. Obligation and generosity on your part was met. When we sat down at our table, the card "Nia". *Im giving my husband a gift card for a concert venue where we live he can choose the show he wants to see. She wanted a very elaborate cake with a lot of decoration. My family is just middle class. Sister is lashing out because she's grieving, hurting, and stressed. Your sister must learn NO=NO. Thanks to everyone who commented in my first post. Stories do NOT have to be AITA but should be seeking advice or feedback on situations. See our ~~*Best Of*~~ "Most Controversial" at /r/AITAFiltered! When my sister initially shared her wedding plans, she also revealed that she was expecting everyone to contribute financially, even beyond the typical wedding gifts. My daughter’s birthday was the day right after and it was perfect because all the family was in town anyways for the wedding. I politely declined to lend her my purse. My cousin received the gift, my friend did not. $5,000 is a drop in the bucket compared to the amount she paid for your college. ADMIN MOD. It’s a happy moment and I was happy to share in it. NTA- You gave a gift. The answer is yes it does. You are not just risking your one life but that of everyone around you. Y’all keep saying I gave them useless stuff, but my BM and everyone else wanted the gifts. Also, My half sister is 11 years older than me, I used to go to my sisters house some weekends for girls nights with her other half sister from her mom's second marriage. She doesn't have an income source or financial stability that I do. It was his suggestion to do this. Mom opens it, and it’s a framed ultrasound image showing that my sister is pregnant, about a month along. Help keep the sub engaging! 3trenchcoatminions. I have three young children, 7M, 5F, 3M. Members Online It's your wedding, not your parents or your sister. I 17f live with my mom, my dad, and my two younger sisters. Well kudos to the Dyson marketing team, because I just googled “Dyson air thing for hair” and that looks pretty cool. My favorite wedding gift/wedding story is from 15 years ago, some friends of my wife were getting married. . YTA. My (30sM) sister (30sF) is having her wedding at the tail-end of October, and she has decided, understandably, that she doesn't want any children to be at the wedding, which is perfectly fine. AITA for not giving my nephew his birthday gift. I (32m)was invited to a wedding of an acquaintance of mine named Molly a few months ago. When she fell she fell onto a soft flower"bed". Amy called me selfish and materialistic for not lending it to her for the wedding. My sister did all the same things to me. My (29f) nephew, Josh (12m), is quite spoilt. a long flight. She said the wedding was going to be at a beach near our city, and it will completely be held in the sand: basically a 35 person ceremony right by the water followed by a bonfire and barbecue also in the sand. When my sister received her invitation, hers read “We have reserved 1 seat (s) in your name”. They didn't want it. She was raised not knowing I existed, as were all of her siblings. Half sister is my dad's child. They didn’t aologize to me only fiancé apologised to her. But she needs to stop pushing. AITA for not giving my sister the wedding gift she wanted because of how she treated my girlfriend? My girlfriend Naomi and I have been together for over a decade. So you're not going to waste money on a new frock, nor put in any more effort than any other wedding guest. During this dinner, my sister asked my son (17m) to make her wedding dress. Our parents gave me a flat fee of 10k for a dress which they are giving to my sister too. I do not give gifts that expensive. You'll attend, for her sake, and you'll be quiet and polite. The house is relatively small (only 3bdrm During this dinner, my sister asked my son (17m) to make her wedding dress. A subtle, unexpected surprise. I went to my sister and she said she used "their real name". First, whether your SO gets down on one knee or not, you are, for all intents and purposes, engaged. Not the A-hole. Normally my philosophy is strongly yes, you should buy off the registry if you are getting a gift. 5. In this culture, expensive wedding gifts are not the price of attendance; one assumes that an invitation is a sign of friendship rather than greed. My fiancé (M28) and I (F28) are set to be married in December. My son has always loved design and fashion, he took technical courses in these areas and sewing, and even his friends keep asking for his clothes because they are so beautiful. cheesyfrie. She's actually the child he had after an affair while married to my mom. Here are some of the top comments: During this dinner, my sister asked my son (17m) to make her wedding dress. They've been dating "many years" and have now decided to marry, a "first marriage for both Fucking seriously. Second, you're buying into the notion that your relatives have any say so in any of your decisions. She went through all of her chemo treatments and was in remission for about 2 or so years. I (31 M) have been married to my wonderful wife (33 F) for a year. There is no profit in that at all. She has her cake, her venue, her dress Great. We were given a terminal diagnosis at Nov 9, 2023 · I asked for clarity on what she was asking me to do, and she asked if I would give fewer gifts to my fiancée on Christmas, and keep the rest of what I wanted to get her for before or after we visited. I did not give them the gifts until the day before the wedding. Then she chose to give that speech. I was always a gamer and a reader. 278. When actually I congratulated her in person since I believed it warranted more than a phone call. Your sister is being a spoiled brat and your parents are encouraging this. My sister loved makeup and dolls. Now, I am not comfortable around children of any age. Subreddit Announcements Happy Anniversary, AITA! Follow the link above to learn more We went and check out the event center in which the wedding party will be taking place and we discussed no money will be received from our side, my husband's dad joke about giving his wife (my husband's mom) some money from the wedding gifts in which she said "NO, this is y'all gift". All with gift receipts. She fell in love with this designer gown – we're talking thousands of Not the A-hole. We have been super close throughout high school and even went to the same college and saw each other This year, around November, my younger sister asked in a family chat if we are doing Secret Santa again this year. She was not put up for adoption, because I was the 13th baby, and she was only the 12th. AITA for not attending my sister's wedding? Asshole. Well just this past week Bertram and I sent out our wedding invitations, and they read “We have reserved __ seat(s) in your name. i may have been insensitive to her monetary issuess. After my sister ran out of her husband's life insurance I let her move into my parents house in what was supposed to be a temporary arrangement while she found a job (she was a SAHM). My wife scheduled it for this day because it's the only day certain family on her side can come. Put like $50 or so in a card and call it a day. NTA, OP, your sister is really a bit of a twit. I [33F] was adopted shortly after birth. When people used to ask them what I wanted to be they'd say what my sister wanted to be. (She's more than a decade older and wealthy). I’ve read all of your comments. My younger May 8, 2024 · “Amy doesn’t own any designer bags and really wanted one to complete her wedding look. She doesn't work so can do a midweek wedding. Your SIL is not your sister, she's just a stranger who married your brother. A little backstory: I (F23) have been best friends with a woman I will call Ashley (F24) since 10th grade. NTA, but you're missing a couple of key points here. She's 5 months pregnant and preparing to raise the baby. She also locked this date in before we knew her During my discussion with my sister, she asked me if my husband and I were planning to use the wedding gift money from my parents to do a particular renovation for which we’ve been saving, but I was very confused because the gift, while extremely generous and appreciated, wasn’t nearly enough to cover that. She and my BIL have 3 children and claimed that there is to much cost involved in buying presents for the kids and they wouldn't be able to afford additional presents. zw bo xe vt fa px pk or sh xi